A Poorly Made Cookie


In order to bake a good chocolate chip cookie, one needs flour, baking soda, butter, brown sugar, white sugar, vanilla extract, eggs and chocolate chips. Without any one of these ingredients, the cookie would in all likelihood taste as vulgar as my grandmother’s infamous gefilte fish (trust me: not a good experience). Lets say that for some reason, the eggs are the freshest in the city and the chocolate chips are better than usual, but the brown sugar, vanilla extract and baking soda are practically non-existent. That would make for a pretty fucking gross cookie.

Are NFL draft prospects not the exact same thing? Some attributes that make an NFL player good are speed, strength, poise, hand-eye co-ordination, awareness, height and agility. Just like our chocolate chip cookie, if only a couple of these attributes are above-average, and the rest are just mediocre, then the NFL player will not have a very successful career. This is why the NFL combine is useless, and General Managers who judge and draft players based on combine results are foolish.

The prime perpetrator of this over the past number of years has been none other than the Oakland Raiders’ erratic owner, Al Davis. In 2005, with the 23rd overall pick, he took cornerback Fabian Washington. Not coincidentally, Washington has recorded the fastest ever 40 yard dash time at 4.25 seconds. Washington played a couple decent seasons with Raiders, but did not amount to much. He was traded to the Ravens in 2008. The next year, Davis took DB Michael Huff 7th overall. Huff had recorded a time of 4.34, just .03 off the fastest time for a DB. Huff also had the best bench press numbers for a DB, at 21 reps. The following year, in a seeming trend, the Raiders had the 1st overall pick. If you are a Raiders fan, I can understand if you skip these next few lines. In what could be argued as the biggest draft bust EVER, the Raiders took QB Jamarcus Russell, who was astoundingly fast for his weight, and had a huge arm. Russell put on weight (I mean, a lot of weight. He weighs more than many of the offensive linemen protecting him. Thats a scary thought) and has since been cut. Now I can’t blame Davis for making this choice, as the Raiders desperately needed a QB, and Russell was widely regarded as the top QB of the draft. The other QB in this draft that  was taken in the first round was Brady Quinn. Too bad neither could live up to their post-combine billing. In 2008, Oakland once again possessed a high first rounder, this time 4th overall. Halfback Darren McFadden had recorded the fastest 40 time, and shockingly enough, the Raiders selected him. D-Fad had a breakout season this past year, and is the only one of the Raiders past 6 draft picks that has worked out, at least up until now. 2009 came about, and the Raiders were looking for a wide receiver to jumpstart Jamarcus. maybe even a deep threat. So, with the seventh overall pick, Oakland took Darrius Heyward-Bey. DHB was maybe seen as the 3 or 4th best WR in the draft, behind Michael Crabtree, Jeremy Maclin and Percy Harvin. Not only did DHB have the fastest 40 yard dash time, he also had the highest vertical. There were questions about his hands, but the Raiders took him anyway, thinking that he would be so fast that he could get wide open a few times again for a hail mary from Russell. So far, DHB has combined for 35 catches and not even 500 yards receiving. Jeremy Maclin on the other hand? 126 receptions, 1737 yards and 14 touchdowns. Al Davis and his Raiders have picked largely based on combine stats, taking the fastest player in the draft 3 of the past 5 years, and clearly, they are still not quite where they want to be. Of those 5 draft choices, one has worked out. All you have to do is look at the Raiders to know that if you draft mostly from the combine, it is bad news.

I will end this post with a small anecdote. The other day in class, my friend who just so happens to be a Raiders fan, was bored. I had my computer and was sitting in front of him. He suggested that I watch the combine to spice up the class. I asked  him why I would want to watch that, and he blindly responded that “I guess its interesting. These players will be in the NFL next year”. I turned around and shook my head. Those Raiders fans will never learn.

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  • nic  On March 4, 2011 at 6:31 pm

    You can crap on Al Davis and the Raiders all you want BUT how dare you (yes dare you) bring up the Raiders draft history without mentioning the fact that last year, a corner was turned.

    For the 1st time IN A LONG TIME the Raiders (whether or not Al Davis was pulling the trigger) nailed it…yes NAILED it. Three of the Raiders picks were graded as 1st Rounders when Don banks did a 1st rd re-draft at the end of the year. Lamarr Houston, Jared Veldheer and Jacoby Ford were rock-solid picks and Rolando McClain is the MLB for the next 10 years.

    You can a bash the Raiders all you want, and as a diehard i lovingly bash them all the time…but you can’t crap on a team without sharing the positives. That’s like talking about how great the Steelers were for making the Super Bowl without mentioning they LOST.

    Go Raiders!

  • bob cob  On March 20, 2011 at 12:54 am

    is this post about the combine or about the raiders draft history…..make up your mind…..poorly structured and poorly thought out…..

    • twoguysandasportsblog  On March 20, 2011 at 12:44 pm

      It is about the combine, using the Raiders as an example of a team that relies too much on combine stats. Thanks though!!

      • joe shmoe  On March 21, 2011 at 4:54 pm

        Half the introduction is about the combine, while the whole body (10 times longer than the intro) and the conclusion is about the raiders.

        Also, many teams have proved that the 2nd – 7th rounds are equally as valuable and important as the 1st. The amount of talent in each draft goes far beyond the top 32. Could these “draft busts” also be related to the system oakland has for developing rookies, and the fact that they don’t tweak their system and exploit the strengths of the rookies, allowing them to develop well? New England has made a name for themselves by adjusting their system to allow not-so-big names excel (Welker, Brady, Woodhead, Green-Ellis) and good players become better (McCourty, Moss, Mayo). Drafting and developing good players isn’t a coincidence for the Pats. The Raiders’ developing and accomodating techniques could be equally if not more responsible for their lack of youth success as their scouting and choice of picks.

        Thoughts on this?

      • twoguysandasportsblog  On March 21, 2011 at 5:05 pm

        Thats fair, but its tough to develop a player that isn’t good in the first place. All those NE players you listed are smallish white guys who don’t have a lot of raw talent. The pats work them into their system and make them good players for the Patriots. Danny Woodhead was bad on the Jets because they couldn’t make him work, but the Pats brought him in and defined a role for him. You are right though, developing players in an organization is half the battle. As far as the later picks being just as valuable, this where developing your players is even more crucial. Most of the time these kids don’t have a full skill set like a first rounder might, so an organization has to work with him to make him a better player (see: Brent Grimes, Atlanta Falcons). The point of the article is that you cannot rely on combine skills, because they are never a good indicator as to how a player will perform on the big stage. When all you do is look at combine stats like Al Davis, you already put yourself behind the eight ball as far as development is concerned.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: